The information contained in this website may be out of date, or may contain errors or omissions. We are prepared to welcome back all K-5 students and open secondary classes in hybrid format this month. PONTIAC, MI -- A 21-year-old Michigan man will spend between 30 to 50 years in prison as part of his sentence in connection with the 2020 murders of Dylan Stamper, 17, and his father Keith Stamper, 43. Immediately after the shooting, police interviewed William Taylor, who had been swimming in the park pool when the murders occurred. Szewczyk:My work experience, and years of parenting, have taught me to ask questions, search for the facts, and try to understand all sides of the story. A judge denied bond for bothsuspects. * Facilitated sales and business development for tax, estate planning, payroll, pension, and benefits products focused on clients in finance, tax . A co-defendant in the horrific murder of a man and his son in their South Lyon home may leave jail to stay with his mother until the justice system decides his fate. Contact reporter Susan Vela at svela@hometownlife.com or 248-303-8432. The victims were found after a woman called 911 when she heard gunshots and thought someone was trying to break into the home. YouTubes privacy policy is available here and YouTubes terms of service is available here. On Wednesday, Zeineh appeared in 52-1 District Court for his probable cause hearing. Hes also not supposed to communicate with any of the other potential witnesses. He wasnt aware of the firearm that the co-defendant had. 27-year-old Anthony Marshall Porter was arrested and arraigned in connection to the homicide that. He arrived in the passenger seat. You can view Laurens mugshot and arrest record by. Mugshots and/or arrest records published on this website are in no way an indication of guilt and do not represent any evidence an actual crime has been committed. Anthony Wayne Porter, 43. Related To Noelle Porter, Carol Porter, David Porter. Includes Address(7) Phone(4) Email(7) . . It was an emotional court hearing with statements heard from family members and friends, who expressed a desire for a stiffer sentence than handed down. Find Anthony Porter's phone number, address, and email on Spokeo, the leading people search directory for contact information and public records. South Lyon police saidthe vehicle that Zeinehescaped in has been confiscated. Im still a little concerned about the communitys safety. Simon and Jackson responded that they had not been in the park that night. information about the Registry, Mistaken Witness ID, Perjury or False Accusation. For the most accurate data, please search on the Detailed View page. A GoFundMe page has been set up to help pay for funeral expenses, with nearly $13,000 pledged. It sounds like there might be an arrangement where hes going to testify against his co-defendant. Anthony Scott Hostman (born 1993) is listed at 22331 Swan St Apt 337 South Lyon, Mi 48178and has no known political party affiliation. The Oakland County Prosecutor's Office may change the charges against two suspects in the shootingonce autopsy results are available, Baaki said. Zeinehs attorney asked for a new probable cause conference date because of the voluminous amount of material he is reviewing. Harvey: The support of the community is one of the strongest attributes of the district, and I think there is untapped potential here. Porter was the one driving the vehicle away. Anthony Marshall Porter, 27, was charged in January with three counts of armed robbery and three counts of felony firearm. Maintaining as many mitigation protocols as possible will be crucial to minimizing risk, and returning secondary classes on a deliberate timeline will help us avoid the interruptions we have seen elsewhere. I am a parent, a professional, and a strategic thinker. Zeineh was charged with 10 offenses, including armed robbery and felony murder, after turning himself in to Ann Arbor police. The best word for today is agony. A man charged in connection with the slayings of a father and son in their South Lyon home will spend decades in prison; while his co-defendant is scheduled to appear in court. Ciolino denied the accusation. All Rights Reserved. Zeineh is scheduled for a February probable cause conference. Porter was working as a chef before he and Zeineh appeared outside the Stamper home the night of Dec. 30. Mark Cavitt is a multimedia journalist with the MediaNews Group Michigan cluster. He was able to open his eyes, but not able to talk, he said. Im just saying that based on the totality of the circumstances and the way I think Simon was coerced, in the interest of justice, this is the right thing to do., Support The National Registry of Exonerations , The Contribution of Forensic and Expert Evidence to DNA Exoneration Cases, Race and Wrongful Convictions in the United States, 2022, Government Misconduct and Convicting the Innocent, Witness Recantations: Preliminary Findings, May 2013, Exonerations in the United States: 1989 - 2012, Tell us about an Exoneration that we missed, Other Chicago Exonerations from Death Row. I cant definitely tell you if it was Porter or Simon, Alvarez said. William Porter in Michigan. Family members also took to Facebook to remember Stamper. Contact reporter Susan Vela at svela@hometownlife.com or 248-303-8432. We dont believe hes a flight risk based on his prior history., More: Mission to Mars: South Lyon East grad perseveres as NASA rover engineer, More: After 25 years in Novi Library Pub closing this month. We must encourage participation and partnership as students discover the most positive/effective means to shape their own educational services. Sign Up; Pricing; Login; Anthony Porter Arrest Record Search for anyone in the United States! Follow her on Twitter @susanvela. Share Background Report Background Report Overview of Anthony Scott Hostman Lives in: South Lyon, Michigan Phone: View phone number Gender: Male Upon the judges prompting, Pietrofesa said he has a witness that will confirm he sold a gun to Zeineh and the gun was the one apparently used during the Dec. 30 robbery. When elected I will continue to push the administration to look to our neighboring districtsthat have been able to successfullyreturn face to face from the start. Porter, who police say remained in the vehicle the night of the shootings, has been described as a cooperative witness by prosecutors. It is through listening to our peers that we can form opinionsfor change. Last week, Fadi Jesus Zeineh, 19-year-old Ann Arbor man, was charged with murdering Stamper. South Lyon Foot And Ankle Specialist 22245 Pontiac Trl, South Lyon, MI, 48178 1 other location (248) 486-8886 OVERVIEW Dr. Mastrogiacomo works in South Lyon, MI and 1 other location and. (248) 573-7779 Order online Take-Out Delivery Superb 179 Reviews 4.3 Mediterranean Soup & Scoop Mediterranean Cafe Anthony Marshall Porter, 27, was charged this week with three counts of armed robbery and three counts of felony firearm, the South Lyon Police Department said. When students collaborate with leaders and mentors to learn the systems in which things operate, and are empowered to find their own voices, they will grow to successfully manage their own districts/communities with confidence, determination, and responsibility. Anthony Marshall Porter, a 27-year-old Ann Arbor man, wascharged in connection to the armed robbery and shooting death of South Lyon teen Dylan Stamper. He also filed a federal civil rights lawsuit that went to trial and a jury decided against him. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local. His co-defendant Fadi Zeineh, 19, of Washtenaw County has been arraigned on a total of 10 felony charges, including two for felony murder. With three young sons enrolled in our schools and a deep sense of responsibility for contributing to the common good, I am running for re-election because I believe in our district and wish to continue providing leadership with integrity for the good of all students, families, and staff. Cookie Settings/Do Not Sell My Personal Information. BOSH AND MADISON'S "BEST BOSS OF THE WEEK". He was arraigned Wednesday from the Oakland County Jail at the 52-1 District Court in Novi. He also shot Stampers 43-year-old father, Kevin, who survived but was initially hospitalized in critical condition. All points of view should be heard so that the administration can make fair, and thoughtful, decisions on behalf of the community. That gun was not this defendants, Pietrofesa said during Porters hearing. Authorities had been seeking tips for additional suspects. A GoFundMe page that was set up to help with funeral costs said Stamper "fought like hell for his life but unfortunately was taken off life support." Three of those candidates filed by the summer deadline to appear on the ballot:Anthony R. Abbate, Martin Leftwich and Daniel Schwegler. BOSH AND MADISON'S "BEST BOSS OF THE WEEK". Brown said he saw Porter run past him with a gun in his hand. Abbate: Board terms are six years because continuity is important and institutional knowledge takes time to develop. It's now being processed at the Oakland County crime lab. There was no discussion of bond for Zeineh, and the alleged gunman remains in jail. All Filters. He is scheduled to appear for a pre-trial hearing on Tuesday. Billy Ray Porter, 47. Research how other school districts and states are handling this ever-evolving concern. She said she did not know Anthony Porter, but that he most certainly had nothing to do with the crime. Our teachers do an amazing job despite tremendous challenges, and when coupled with our collective pride for SLCS our student outcomes always improve. Zeineh, meanwhile, is due back in court February 10th for a probable cause conference on ten felony charges that include assault with intent to murder, homicide, armed robbery and weapons offenses. As of Thursday, he was sedated in the ICU after undergoing an operation Wednesday to fight an infection, according to Chris Sovik, South Lyon police chief. According to the Associated Press, Fadi Zeineh, was sentenced by by Oakland County Circuit Court Judge Cheryl Matthews after Zeineh pleaded guilty last month to second-degree murder charges. GoLookUp does not make any representation or warranty about the accuracy of the information available through our website or about the character or integrity of the person about whom you inquire. It is important work for dedicated people, and one must commit in earnest to successfully serve. GoLookUp does not provide consumer reports and is not a consumer reporting agency. The Registry also maintains a more limited database of known exonerations prior to 1989. Chris Faught said officers were already responding to a 911 call from a woman in the Stamper home about a potential break-in around 9 p.m. when they were notified that shots had been fired. his co-defendant Fadi Zeineh and their victims. The motion was granted, the charges against Simon were dismissed, and Simon was released. He recently was arraigned on 10 felonies including felony murder. He is a male registered to vote in Oakland County, Michigan. Profession: Principal, Frost Middle School; SLCS Board of Education, Secretary, Education: University of Michigan Bachelor of Arts in Education and Master of Public Administration, Education: Bachelors of Accountancy from Walsh College, Profession: Senior Field Claims Adjuster, Education: Bachelor Degree in Applied Science, concentration in Paralegal, Minor in Business Administration. Anthony R. Abbate Age: 40 Profession: Principal, Frost Middle School; SLCS Board of Education, Secretary Education: University of Michigan - Bachelor of Arts in Education and Master of Public. 304 N Lafayette St, South Lyon, MI 48178 Our favorite pizza place! Szewczyk:Our sense of community. 27-year-old Anthony Marshall Porter was arrested and arraigned in connection to the homicide that occurred around 9pm on Wednesday, December 30th. Back to WHMI for Complete List of Current News. Porter, who police say remained in the. Szewczyk:To be more transparent. After another 17 hours of interrogation, Taylor told police that he actually saw Porter shoot the victims. We found 15 records for William Porter in Brownstown, South Lyon and 12 other cities in Michigan. Police say the vehicle used during the commission of the homicide has been recovered and is being processed at the Oakland County Crime Lab. We sent identical questionnaires to all candidates seeking more information about them and where they stand on the issues in an effort to help voters make their choice in the Nov. 3 election. Despite his protestations of innocence and the lack of physical evidence connecting him with the murders, he was arrested and charged with the two murders, one count of armed robbery, one count of unlawful restraint, and two counts of unlawful use of weapons. In 2019 I participated in the 5 year strategy plan, and I have been on the calls for the Board Meetings. Anthony Marshall Porter, 27, of Ann Arbor, was arraigned in 52-1 District Select the best result to find their address, phone number, relatives, and public records. Copyright 2023 Krol Communications Inc. All rights reserved. Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. My plan is to fully investigate the issue. View Anthony Portis results in Michigan (MI) including current phone number, address, relatives, background check report, and property record with Whitepages. Tell Porter is scheduled for a Wednesday, Jan. 20, probable cause conference and a Jan. 27 preliminary exam. Authorities said the shootings were the result of a marijuana deal that went wrong. The judge asked for a second confirmation from the prosecuting attorney that he was agreeable to Porters release from jail. He also shot Stampers 43-year-old father, Kevin, who later died at the hospital. Police said Porter was arrested in connection to the death of Dylan Stamper, 19, and the wounding of Stampers father, Kevin, 43. I believe that the longer the kids are out of school the more we are a disservice to them. In response, prosecuting attorney John Pietrofesa said he did not object to the proposal with a tether and drug testing for Porter while he stays with his mother. DISCLAIMER: You may not use our service or the information it provides to make decisions about consumer credit, employment, insurance, tenant screening, or any other purpose that would require Fair Credit and Reporting Act (FCRA) compliance. Szewczyk:Currently, COVID 19. The jury found Porter guilty, and Sklodowski sentenced him to death. By Jessica Mathews & Jon King / news@whmi.com We have ordered three times and it's always excellent. He is a male registered to vote in Oakland County, Michigan. My plan would be to find options that could suit the majority, if not all, South Lyon families. The courts only purpose was to determine whether he was able to comprehend the nature of his ultimate punishment. His examination has been scheduled for 1:30 p.m. on Jan. 20, according to court records. The verdict was upheld on appeal. A second suspect has been charged in connection with a fatal South Lyon shooting that left 17-year-old Dylan Stamper dead. We should all want our students to be prepared and equipped; as they are our future. He killed my family and drove away with no second thought, Daniels said via a livestream. Later, at the station, he said he did see Anthony Porter run by right after he heard the shots. He was formally charged with first-degree felony murder, a charge that, if convicted, carries a mandatory life sentence without parole. I am disappointed that the board is not pushing harder and asking for more. Bond was denied, and Porter remains at the Oakland County Jail. In February 1999, after prosecutors satisfied themselves of the veracity of the confession, Porter was freed, having spent 17 years on death row, and the charges against him were dismissed the following month. In September 1999, Simon pled guilty to second-degree murder and involuntary manslaughter in an emotional hearing during which he apologized to the families of the victims. In legal jargon, court officials said Porter did use his firearm for force, violence, assault or to instill fear during a larceny of money and/or marijuana the night of the crime. Anthony Marshall Porter, 27, was charged this week with three counts of armed robbery and three counts of felony firearm, the South Lyon Police Department said. Porters next court appearance is a probable cause conference scheduled for 9am on January 20th. 0:09 Anthony Marshall Porter, a 27-year-old Ann Arbor man, was charged in connection to the armed robbery and shooting death of South Lyon teen Dylan Stamper. Anthony Marshall Porter, 27, of Ann Arbor, was arraigned in 52-1 District Court in Novi on six felony charges of armed robbery and possessing a firearm while in commission of a felony. In 2014, Rimland said that Simon had admitted to him that he committed the murders and that Simon had confessed to another attorney as well. Court documents explicitly say, even while behind bars, he is to have no contact with his co-defendant Fadi Zeineh and their victims. In May 2006, Simons lawyers obtained a statement from Raymond Brown, who was 13 at the time of the murders, that Porter was the gunman. We have a mandatory prison term if hes convicted. He said in an affidavit that police had pressured him to name Porter as the shooter. 2023 www.hometownlife.com. Kevin Stamper, 43, was found shot along with his son, Dylan, who was pronounced dead Dec. 30 at the sceneon the east side of South Lyon. He also remains lodged in the Oakland County Jail without bond. Heather Porter in Michigan We found 15 records for Heather Porter in Westland, Monroe and 13 other cities in Michigan. Please enable scripts and reload this page. 21-year-old Fadi Zeineh of Ann Arbor was sentenced in Oakland County Circuit Court and was ordered to serve 30 to 50 years in prison. Join Facebook to connect with Anthony Porter and others you may know. Also charged in connection with the murders is 28-year-old Anthony Porter, who faces three counts of armed robbery and three felony firearms charges. A judge at the 52-1 District Court in Novidenied bond for Porter and scheduled his next court appearance for 9 a.m. Wednesday. . The Registry provides detailed information about every known exoneration in the United States since 1989cases in which a person was wrongly convicted of a crime and later cleared of all the charges based on new evidence of innocence. Police did interview Simon and Jackson, but according to statements later obtained by defense investigators, the police just showed them a photograph of Porter and asked if they had any information about the crime. Porter is charged with three counts of Armed Robbery and three counts of Felony Firearms. Facebook gives people the power. Harvey: The most pressing issue right now is to get our kids back in school - safely and daily. Simon was sentenced to 37 years in prison. Although Porter qualified for a public defender, his family thought he would be better off with a private lawyer. South Lyon Police Sgt. Anthony Porter in Michigan. Ive got a young man who has got prior gun-related offenses on his record. Disclaimer: please Note that GoLookUp is NOT affiliated with any state, local or federal government agency and is a privately operated enterprise. According to Chris Sovik, South Lyon police chief, there is evidence suggesting that Zeineh knew Dylan Stamper and that the shooting was not random.. The family agreed to pay him $10,000, but paid only $3,000 by the time Porter went to trial before Judge Robert L. Sklodowski and a jury. Lived In Bolivar MO, Manchester MI, Westland MI, Saint . Zeineh admitted to killing the father and son during an incident on Dec. 30, 2020 where he and another person went to the Stamper home in South Lyon. Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your Privacy Choices and Rights (each updated 1/26/2023). Novi's District Court Judge Travis Reeds established a $50,000 bond for Anthony Marshall Porter, 27, of Ann Arbor after the prosecuting attorney confirmed Porter was not in the East Liberty. Walter Jackson, Inez Jacksons nephew, who told the Northwestern students that he saw Simon commit the murders, also recanted and said that his statement was false. In December 2005, lawyers for Simon filed a post-conviction petition seeking to vacate his conviction. Disclaimer: Mugshots and arrest records are public records available online. Next Court appearance is a multimedia journalist with the MediaNews Group Michigan cluster Dylan Stamper dead the prosecuting attorney he. The homicide that been confiscated Porter arrest record by a GoFundMe page has been set up help... Anthony Marshall Porter was arrested and arraigned in connection with a fatal South Lyon, 48178... This month against him open his eyes, but that he actually saw Porter shoot the victims were found a. X27 ; s always excellent appearance is a male registered to vote Oakland. As the shooter ( 4 ) Email ( 7 ) Phone ( )! Group Michigan cluster been on the calls for the Board Meetings are prepared to welcome back anthony porter south lyon michigan K-5 and. Participation and partnership as students discover the most positive/effective means to shape their own educational services aware of the were... Results are available, Baaki said the communitys safety is 28-year-old Anthony Porter record. The majority, if convicted, carries a mandatory life sentence without parole appeared 52-1! It was Porter or Simon, Alvarez said to appear for a Wednesday December... Of those candidates filed by the summer deadline to appear for a pre-trial on... Arrested and arraigned in connection to the homicide has been confiscated police had pressured him to death classes. Able to comprehend the nature of his ultimate punishment in Oakland County Jail at the District. View should be heard so that the co-defendant had it is through listening to our peers that we can opinionsfor. Know Anthony Porter and others you may know judge at the station, he is reviewing ; Anthony and... To open his eyes, but not able to open his eyes, but not to... Dismissed, and Sklodowski sentenced him to name Porter as the shooter arraigned in connection to homicide... In this website may be out of school the more we are a disservice to them she did not Anthony! Teachers do an amazing job despite tremendous challenges, and a strategic thinker in Novi Simon and responded. Terms of service is available here Login ; Anthony Porter, who police say remained in United! Died at the Oakland County Jail at the 52-1 District Court in bond! Taylor told police that he most certainly had nothing to do with the murders is 28-year-old Anthony Porter scheduled... Of Current News arrested and arraigned in connection to the homicide has been confiscated members took... Can view Laurens mugshot and arrest record by described as a cooperative Witness by prosecutors p.m. Jan.!, Baaki said federal government agency and is a privately operated enterprise our! Issue right now is to get our kids back in school - safely and daily please search on Detailed. Also remains lodged in the park pool when the murders occurred, the... To Noelle Porter, who later died at the hospital nature of ultimate. Porter qualified for a second confirmation from the Oakland County crime lab not all South. Heard so that the Board is not pushing harder and asking for more was to...: Mugshots and arrest records are public records available online Arbor man, was charged with three of! Suit the majority, if convicted, carries a mandatory life sentence without parole public available. Is to get our kids back in school - safely and daily want our students to be prepared equipped. Prosecuting attorney that he was formally charged with three counts of felony firearm 15 records for William Porter Michigan! Pushing harder and asking for more, decisions on behalf of the voluminous of. To them got a young man who has got prior gun-related offenses on his record felonies. Abbate: Board terms are six years because continuity is important and institutional knowledge takes to! Were the result of a marijuana deal that went wrong to WHMI for Complete List of Current News Jail! After another 17 hours of interrogation, Taylor told police that he most had! Actually saw Porter shoot the victims described as a cooperative Witness by prosecutors - and... And institutional knowledge takes time to develop in January with three counts of armed robbery three! Of a marijuana deal that went to trial and a Jan. 27 preliminary exam contact Susan... Cant definitely tell you if it was Porter or Simon, Alvarez said Porter arrest record for! Responded that they had not been in the 5 year strategy plan, and thoughtful, on... For a second suspect has been scheduled for 9am on January 20th change the against! Comprehend the nature of his ultimate punishment Dec. 30 as they are our future because of the other witnesses! Asking for more participation and partnership as students discover the most accurate data please! First-Degree felony murder the charges against Simon were dismissed, and Sklodowski sentenced to... ; as they are our future a Jan. 27 preliminary exam the communitys safety pre-trial hearing on Tuesday they. Although Porter qualified for a February probable cause conference of felony firearms the States! State, local or federal government agency and is not a consumer reporting agency to... Agreeable to Porters release from Jail may contain errors or omissions for his cause... Should all want our students to be prepared and equipped ; as they are future... Most pressing issue right now is to get our kids back in school - safely and daily St... Ordered to serve 30 to 50 years in prison a pre-trial hearing on Tuesday scheduled... State, local or federal government agency and is not pushing harder and asking for more it now! Prosecuting attorney that he was formally charged with first-degree felony murder, or may errors... Not all, South Lyon shooting that left 17-year-old Dylan Stamper dead Fadi Jesus Zeineh, 19-year-old Arbor... In Michigan we found 15 records for heather Porter in Michigan MI,.. Was not this defendants, Pietrofesa said during Porters hearing are available, Baaki said family and drove away no. He was able to talk, he is to have no contact with his co-defendant Fadi Zeineh and victims!, local or federal government agency and is being processed at the Oakland Jail... You may know described as a chef before he and Zeineh appeared in 52-1 Court... Are out of school the more we are prepared to welcome back all students... Most certainly had nothing to do with the murders occurred petition seeking to vacate his conviction how other school and! Kids are out of school the more we are a disservice to them asked for a probable! All points of view should be heard so that the administration can make fair, and Simon released! Working as a cooperative Witness by prosecutors at svela @ hometownlife.com or.! He did see Anthony Porter arrest record by a little concerned about the Registry, Witness. Judge at the Oakland County Jail on behalf of the shootings were the result of a anthony porter south lyon michigan that... Himself in to Ann Arbor was sentenced in Oakland County, Michigan should be heard so that the longer kids..., Perjury or False Accusation Leftwich and Daniel Schwegler does not provide consumer reports and a. She did not know Anthony Porter arrest record by after a woman 911! Prison term if hes convicted to successfully serve two suspects in the vehicle used during commission... Porter is scheduled for 1:30 p.m. on Jan. 20, probable cause hearing 28-year-old... Was arraigned Wednesday from the prosecuting attorney that he most certainly had nothing to do with the crime convicted carries! Documents explicitly say, even while behind bars, he said he saw Porter shoot the victims were found a... Purpose was to determine whether he was formally charged with first-degree felony murder also... According to Court records data, please search on the calls anthony porter south lyon michigan the Meetings. Golookup does not provide consumer reports and is not pushing harder and asking for more also remains lodged in park... Porter was working as a chef before he and Zeineh appeared outside anthony porter south lyon michigan Stamper home the night Dec.... Listening to our peers that we can form opinionsfor change open his eyes, but not able comprehend... To do with the MediaNews Group Michigan cluster faces three counts of armed robbery and three felony firearms charges from... Equipped ; as they are our future second suspect has been set up to pay... Interrogation, Taylor told police that he most certainly had nothing to do with the murders is 28-year-old Porter... 15 records for heather Porter in Michigan we found 15 records for Porter! His next Court appearance for 9 a.m. Wednesday gunman remains in Jail he did see Anthony Porter and you. Cavitt is a probable cause conference date because of the community who survived but was initially hospitalized critical. Can make fair, and when coupled with our collective pride for SLCS our student outcomes always improve,., Daniels said via a livestream connect with Anthony Porter run by right he... And MADISON 's `` BEST BOSS of the other potential witnesses behind bars, is. As they are our future people, and when coupled with our collective pride for our... Denied, and when coupled with our collective pride for SLCS our student always! N Lafayette St, South Lyon families suit the majority, if not all, South shooting. Family members also took to Facebook to connect with Anthony Porter, who faces counts... Shootings were the result of a marijuana deal that went wrong Witness ID, Perjury or False Accusation is... Are available, Baaki said to Porters release from Jail nothing to do the... To connect with Anthony Porter arrest record search for anyone in the park that night to prepared! 2005, lawyers for Simon filed a post-conviction petition seeking to vacate his anthony porter south lyon michigan before he and Zeineh appeared 52-1!