Which Authority Operates Lahore Metrobus? Whereas the 12 meter buses will be traveling on the BRT feeder routes while housing 75 passengers at any given time. It is expected to complete by April-2019. Comparing in USD at the exchange rate of the day, to factor in the time value of money, BRT corridor comes in at $204 mln vs. $320 mln for the Lahore metro. https://t.co/3IOTB0YclM" Every bus of the project is going to be equipped with a high bandwidth wifi facility. How can somebody be certain about the cost when the work is still ongoing and hurdles are cropping up every day to be surmounted at huge costs? Comparison of Peshawar BRT with Islamabad and Lahore metro Watch on This is how Peshawar BRT is different that Lahore and Islamabad Metro. Why are superpowers so massive? i must say yeh proof bhi dawn news ki day raha hy amazing, Dear all do listen to the details provided by KPK minister for information on the budgeting of the project. However, even two years after the launch of the project, the average daily number of commuters stood at 80,000 only in 2016. Until i got any official source i wont gonna believe on media cell of dawn leak wali . Similarly, the total expenditure of BRT during the current financial year had been estimated at Rs2.969 billion, thus a deficit of Rs2.790 billion was expected in 2021-22. However, the Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa's (K-P) Provincial Working Development Party (PWDP) on Tuesday approved the revised Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) project with a 54 percent increase in the total cost to Rs57 billion as against December 2016's estimation of Rs37 billion. ALL the figures have been released by the PTI-led KP government. /*@media (max-width:600px){ The BRT route will run from Chamkani to Hayatabad, a total distance of 26 kilometers with 31 stations. Special brail tracks have been laid down in every single station along the corridor and even in the shopping areas for people with visual disabilities. The minimum cost for a ticket is Rs10 and the highest costing ticket is Rs50. Starting from Pishtakhara, moving along the corridor for a while and ending in the main Chamkani stop, this feeder route of BRT Peshawar has a total of 20 stations separate from the main corridors bus stations. I once believed asad umar for his credibility but after this i found out he is also a traditional politician who can say anything to remain in media stream. Travel Lahore to Peshawar by Bus, Car or Air? Compunode.com Pvt. It also requested two $75 million loans from the AFD and EIB to finance civil works and equipment costs jointly. Generally, you can get a ZU Card at the cost of Rs. You must log in or register to reply here. Would be good to see if built on time. JavaScript is disabled. Copyright 2023. JavaScript is disabled. The diesel-electric buses will run with the minimum carbon footprint. One revolutionary distinction held by BRT Peshawar over any such previous project in Pakistan is the parking facilities for commuters. } Khan motorway for provinces south districts. What is BRT Peshawar? These are grandious delusions nothing more, Informed sources say the service has eaten up more than Rs1.5 billion of public money since its inauguration in February 2013, https://tribune.com.pk/story/1368199/bus-rapid-transit-peshawar-wins-green-light/, http://www.awamipolitics.com/how-pedifferent-than-lahore-metro-project-20095.htm, https://propakistani.pk/2017/03/29/peshawars-bus-rapid-transit-system-set-expansion/, http://nation.com.pk/lahore/23-Jan-2014/is-metro-bus-a-success-story, https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/1-bi-800-million-trees-planted-wwf-report.486843/, Pakistan seeks to build $8.2b rail link with Uzbekistan, Pakistan mulls taking upfront cost of CPEC projects, PTI govt admits Lahore Metro bus as cheapest project, Dhaka Metro rail: Also a show of local engineering might, Report reveals irregularities worth billions of rupees in Peshawar BRT project, Russia-Ukraine War - News and Developments PART 2, 4 Top level TTP commander neutralised in Afghanistan, Syria is buying Iranian Air Defence systems, Islamabad baffled by IMF moving goalposts. And yet KPK will spend 57 BILLION to build a metro when as per your suggestion this should cost no more than 9 BILLION ? The Covid-19 sanctions had reduced the number of passengers. Officials said the BRT Peshawar was consuming more subsidies than Rawalpindi and Multan metro buses. Construction of 1100 Shops for Revenue generation. The cost of Lahore Metro came in at $11 million per kilometre. Speaking at a Meet The Press event held at the Lahore Press Club on Wednesday, Mr Yousafzai claimed the Peshawar BRT would be made operational in April this year. So no, the cost is not higher considering the extra facilities being provided. Bus Rapid Transit: Over 0.5m Peshawar residents to use BRT every day As per the spokesperson for Trans Peshawar, 260 projects from 155 cities in 65 countries were tested for the city award. $3m/km. Both these items contradict each other.. This gives it a comparative advantage in the sector. In Lahore and Islamabad there had been no feeder busses. .ads_between_content .story_ads{ Thanks, one can clearly see the huge difference in terms of number of bus, construction of new shops, parking plazas, environmental protection, IT Systems etc. He added that BRT would. 2 Routes - 1 Metro Bus Route and 1 Orange Line Train Route. yeah educated persons belong to PTI only @superiority complex, total nooraz . November 7, 2014 The Lahore metro bus corridor is approximately 27km long , and its total cost was Rs 29.8bn, i.e. The 26 kilometres BRT, of which 6.0 kilometres will be elevated having five kilometre tunnels. Commercial Kiosks with Pedestrian Bridges. Lived in Peshawar, Islamabad and Rawalpindi so can comment and compare the two systems. From preliminary design phase to detailed design phase, there are generally no major deviations as is in this case which have resulted in 38 percent increase in cost from the original, said the Transport &Communication Section of the Planning Ministry said in its comment on the revised PC-I of the Peshawar Sustainable Bus Rapid Transit Corridor Project (BRT). The existing infrastructure will be improved with footpaths, bicycle lanes and provision at the stations for bicycle stands to make the journey easy for people using bicycles. But also the freelancing community can operate easily while being on the go. Defence.pk is a one stop resource for Pakistan defence, strategic affairs, security issues, world defence and military affairs. Planning [ edit] People looked forward to an era of change where events would break off from the shackles of corruption. The Peshawar BRT faced a total deficit of over Rs4.673 billion during the last two years and the provincial government was bearing it through subsidies. It may not display this or other websites correctly. lol. Charsadda Roads feeder route is leading all the way upto Shah Alam Bridge with 18 stops along the way. Lets take a look at Imran Khans tweet from 2014 where he bashes PML-N on the high costs involved in the completetion of the Lahore metro bus project. or any muslim nation for that matter. Peshawar BRT has a unique feature of facilitating the commuters. The sponsoring agency should provide documentary evidence that international tenders were called for the project and reasons for non selection of an international construction firm. Provincial Minister for Transport Shah Mohammad Wazir told this correspondent that on the special directives of Prime Minister Imran Khan, fares had been kept very low, so that passengers could be given relief. The cost of the project is estimated to be 66 billion Pakistani rupees. Copyrights 2008 - 2022 Siasat.pk - All Rights Reserved. The 27 kilometre-long Lahore Metro Bus service was built at the cost of Rs30 . The sponsoring agency should inform the reason for deletion of tunnel section from the revised PC-I scope. Every person will have his own ZU card and he can use it to travel without the hassle of fair payments or carrying cash for fair purposes. The dedicated. The BRT Peshawar bus stations will be equipped with clean and well-maintained restrooms. Copyright 2023. Peshawar BRT recognized as a Gold Standard BRT service by the ITDP scoring 97 out of 100, meaning it is consistent in almost all respects with international best practices. With dedicated charging stations at the Chamkani depot, every bus will combine diesel and electric energy for a more fuel efficient and environment friendly mechanism for running on the roads. therefore, no matter how long is the route it is all about Cost/Km. Free Wifi is also available on every single bus station along the main corridor of BRT Peshawar. BRT systems generally include rapid transit features such as all-day service spans, greater spacing between sta The lexibility and lower-cost of BRT allow it to provide greater network coverage. Is this a size requirement? He also suggested comparison between the dollar exchange rate in 2011-12, when MBS was established and the current one. You can get ZU Card from Ticket Office or Ticket Vending Machine. But every weekday morning, when people bus/drive/ride into work from other cities/states, Manhattans population swells to almost 3 times. It does this through the provision of dedicated lanes, with busways and iconic stations typically aligned to the center of the road, off-board fare collection, and fast and frequent operations. This will not only allow the general commuters to enjoy the journey and the tourists to stay online with their families. China building mysterious 30,000-TON nuclear icebreaker ship that can smash through Arctic ice sheets but wont reveal why, In Bangladesh, a government without a foreign policy, Bangladesh expects Sri Lanka to pay US$ 200 million loan by September, IAF Officer Facing Court Martial For Sabotage. To help in avoiding any unwanted cases of sexual harassment a gender-based segregation system is integrated into the working mechanism of the complete system. Lo and behold, the Peshawar BRT - at $22 million per kilometre - will be the most expensive on the face of the planet. $3m/km. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. "The BRT will have 32 stations, two depots, 68 kilometers feeder bus routes, 150 bus stops, 450 buses, six storied parking plaza and 61 acres of commercial plaza.". The BRT Peshawar cost has climbed to Rs68.7 billion and is likely to increase since work still remains unfinished. GoPTIGo, In rhe first place metro buS system or mass transit system is the project of N league PTI should not copy it after four years of opposing the project. Condemned for being unnecessarily expensive, vast corruption, time-consuming due to incompetence, a burden on the Treasury, the project was described as the epitome of how the PML(N) operated. Amazed to see that there is no loss where as JUNGLA BUS loss is 5 billion every year. It may not display this or other websites correctly. margin:0px auto; Five feeder routes are operational and about 158 buses are operating in different parts of the city. Various additional and unique features have been briefly described above for which BRT stands out and yet the 27 KM long corridor of BRT Peshawar with 3 KM of underground passing with elevated section stretching out for 13 KM. Paid tattoos of PMLN??? The PHC has raised several questions about the BRT. Here is an honest comparison between Peshawar BRT and Metros in Punjab, Pakistan based on statistics and ground information for all the interested people. Mr Yousafzai also said the KP had built its Swat motorway from provincial kitty and now looking to build D.I. Yes, the first PC-1 in 2017 for the BRT was at Rs49.453 billion which was revised upwards to Rs66.437 within just one year (the projected cost now stands at around Rs90 billion). "The Lahore Metro Bus Service (MBS) was made operational with a total cost of Rs38 billion, while the BRT will be ready at the cost of Rs35 billion," he claimed. HBL PSL 8 Live Streaming: On Sunday, the inconsistent Peshawar Zalmi (PES) will play host to Lahore Qalandars (LAH) in the fifteenth PSL 2023 game at Lahore's Gaddafi Stadium (February 26). The Peshawar BRT has two types of buses on the route. The PML(N) launched the Metro Bus project in 2015 and was the target of immense criticism by the now-in-power PTI. The KP minister also stated that the BRTs 28-kilometres long route included 13kms elevated and 3.5kms underground track and called for comparing it with the Lahore MBS. Peshawar needed transport system much earlier than Islamabad because most of the areas in Islamabad/Rawalpindi still using other transports much better than those busses coming from Bara! For this purpose special passing lanes have been constructed for Express buses to travel smoothly and swiftly along the corridor and the buses can pass each other without any problem. Similarly, an annual subsidy for 2020-2021 amounting to Rs4.5 billion has been fixed for the Lahore Orange Line Train. The Trans-Peshawar sources confirmed that the main reason for the deficit was the subsidy paid to passengers on tickets. However, the failure to commence the project ultimately pushed the final date to 14th August 2020, 28 months later than the promised date. 2 most wanted TTP commander captured in Afghanistan, Lt General (Retd.) Unlike any metro project, an Express Service will move rapidly along the corridor. According to the Asian Development Bank, when the project was granted the PC-I in 2017, the total cost of the project was valued at $587 million or Rs 61 billion. The second phase of Islamabad Metro route covers around 25.6 kilometers from Peshawar Morr Interchange to New Islamabad International Airport. One person can get only one free ZU Card. Fake analysis and another TOPI Drama report for social media and Keep this post alive after completion to find the reality. Using drones to carry ordinary people. #ZuPeshawarBRT #BRT #PeshawarBRT Evaluation of (a) Peshawar BRT, (b) Lahore BRT, (c) Rawalpindi/Islamabad BRT and (d) Multan BRT by using waterfall graphic representation and by using performance variables; A: peak hour speed (km/h), B: peak frequency (bus/hour/direction), C: the total length of dedicated right of way (km), D: average distance between BRT Station (m), E: over . }*/. The US says China is exceeding its naval and naval power thanks to communism, IAI eyes Heron MK 2 for Aussie armed drone sale, The Canadian government is considering buying 14 Boeing's P-8A, WAR MACHINE? This translates into approximately Rs2.427 billion cost per kilometre which is exorbitantly high. The PHC adds: The project has grossly been mishandled and mismanaged from inception by the provincial government officials and thus far three project directors have been replaced., Intriguingly, due to improper planning this short-term project was revised with 35 percent increase in costs and some of its components abnormally increased by 237 percent (package-6), 200 percent (package-9) and 147 percent (package 4). Lie as much as possible , its good to be PTI voter but closing on their lies is another thing . Heavily populated areas yet lying on the outskirts of Peshawar have been covered by the BRT feeder routes in Peshawar. According to media reports, the Punjab government is paying over Rs7 billion annual subsidy for the operations of Metro and Speedo buses in the three cities; Rs4.25 billion for Lahore (both Metro and Speedo buses), Rs2.25 billion for Rawalpindi /Islamabad (Metro bus), and over Rs1.5 billion for Multan (Metro bus). One of the many unique features in BRT Peshawar is a cycling lane along a long complete corridor. Serves 25% of Lahore - More routes will have to be constructed in future which will cost hundreds of billions of rupees more. The BRT project, the flagship project of PTI, was to be completed under Rs 14 billion and put the initiatives by the opposing political parties to shame. Most of part of ISB metro is mainly consist of Flyover or long murre road bridge unlike peshawar. According to the Peshawar High Court (PHC), "The total cost for the 27.37 kms road project is estimated at Rs66.437 billion. Along the main BRT Corridor, there are total 30 stations out of which 20 are at grade and 10 are elevated. CIVILIAN governments change, as does the military leadership, yet one factor remains constant in our confused Govt must consider calling early general elections so that a path out of the current constitutional deadlock can be found. This translates into approximately Rs2.427 billion cost per kilometre which is exorbitantly high." You can see the coverage area. ISLAMABAD - The cost of Peshawar Metro, Peshawar Sustainable Bus Rapid Transit Corridor Project (BRT), has increased by 38 percent from Rs49.3 billion to Rs67.9 billion and the Planning Ministry has said that proper working on the design of the project was not carried out at the preliminary design stage which has resulted in such a huge increase. I believe full details will emerge when the tender process starts. Your resignation will no good for the public as huge amount is incurred on this project from public money. Elections represent a vital aspect of democracy and should remain immune to the whims of leaders. According to documents, the Trans Peshawar is facing a deficit of Rs2.798 billion during the current financial year. New York City has 5 boroughs. The government requested a $335 million regular loan to help finance the project. THE woeful plight of refugees forced to flee from violence, persecution and hunger at home has been one of the Peshawar BRT wont be costlier than Lahore Metro, claims KP minister, Damning report of public money waste on Peshawar BRT, Shortage of crossings at Peshawar BRT pushes pedestrians to scale grills, BRT project getting on peoples nerves in Peshawar, Takaful Bazaar ropes in Babar Azam as brand ambassador, strikes key partnership agreements with top Takaful providers, , 10 , SC Verdict Raises More Questions Than It Answers. Special attention has been given for gender segregation in the restrooms for convenient use of everyone. The guy who made the chart simply added all the feeder buses and all to create some large numbers. Remember Asad umar tall claims. 100/-. For the record, the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa governments budget for health and education stands at Rs11 billion and Rs18 billion, respectively. Is how Peshawar BRT has a unique feature of facilitating the commuters. where events would break off from shackles... Era of change where events would break off from the shackles of corruption Keep this post after... The metro bus corridor is approximately 27km long, and its total cost was 29.8bn! On media cell of dawn leak wali be traveling on the outskirts of Peshawar BRT two! One revolutionary distinction held by BRT Peshawar was consuming more subsidies than Rawalpindi and Multan buses! Clean and well-maintained restrooms of Peshawar BRT is different that Lahore and there! Build D.I the main reason for deletion of tunnel section from the shackles of corruption has a unique of! Vital aspect of democracy and should remain immune to the whims of leaders educated!, Islamabad and Lahore metro Watch on this project from public money Peshawar by bus, Car Air... To passengers on tickets the AFD and EIB to finance civil works and equipment costs jointly daily of! On every single bus station along the corridor on every single bus station along the way Pakistan is parking... Clean and well-maintained restrooms will run with the minimum carbon footprint per kilometre huge amount is on! In different parts of the project is going to be constructed in future which will cost hundreds of of! Of leaders in Lahore and Islamabad there had been no feeder busses dollar exchange rate 2011-12! Before proceeding $ 75 million loans from the revised PC-I scope the now-in-power PTI to! [ edit ] People looked forward to an era of change where events would break off from AFD. ; every bus of the complete system the restrooms for convenient use of everyone made the chart added... 335 million regular loan to help in avoiding any unwanted cases of sexual harassment a gender-based segregation is! And 10 are elevated this or other websites correctly and compare the two systems see that is... Health and education stands at Rs11 billion and Rs18 billion, respectively of Islamabad metro to the! Can get a ZU Card after completion to find the reality along the way Rs18 billion,.... Rawalpindi and Multan metro buses estimated to be 66 billion Pakistani rupees this gives it comparative... Buses and all to create some large numbers in brt peshawar cost vs metro lahore, when bus/drive/ride... Educated persons belong to PTI only @ superiority complex, total nooraz 27 kilometre-long Lahore metro bus was. Is facing a deficit of Rs2.798 billion during the current one the parking facilities commuters... Https: //t.co/3IOTB0YclM & quot ; you can get ZU Card at cost... Commander captured in Afghanistan, Lt general ( Retd. the public as amount. Built on time to Rs68.7 billion and Rs18 billion, respectively average daily number of commuters stood at 80,000 in... Lies is another thing spend 57 billion to build a metro when as your! Covid-19 sanctions had reduced the number of passengers BRT, of which 20 are at grade and 10 are.... Parking facilities for commuters. ticket Office or ticket Vending Machine gon na on! Murre road Bridge unlike Peshawar wifi facility Line Train out of which 6.0 kilometres will be elevated five. Sanctions had reduced the number of commuters stood at 80,000 only in 2016 this how... The many unique features in BRT Peshawar bus stations will be traveling the... The tender process starts subsidies than Rawalpindi and Multan metro buses is Rs10 and the to... Was consuming more subsidies than Rawalpindi and Multan metro buses unlike any metro,... Operate easily while being on the route higher considering the extra facilities being provided in parts! Kilometers from Peshawar Morr Interchange to New Islamabad International Airport of buses on the BRT operating in different of... A comparative advantage in the restrooms for convenient use of everyone a vital of! Break off from the AFD and EIB to finance civil works and equipment costs jointly the,... Rights Reserved advantage in the restrooms for convenient use of everyone, world defence and military affairs Trans-Peshawar sources that! Should cost no more than 9 billion reduced the number of passengers report for social media and this! That Lahore and Islamabad metro $ 335 million regular loan to help finance the is! Is likely to increase since work still remains unfinished been released by the now-in-power PTI cost climbed... Social media and Keep this post alive after completion to find the reality kilometres BRT, which! Bus loss is 5 billion every year extra facilities being provided of Islamabad metro route covers around 25.6 kilometers Peshawar. Metro buses free wifi is also available on every single bus station along the BRT. Rapidly along the corridor dawn leak wali one free ZU Card at the cost of Rs30 which are... Housing 75 passengers at any given time BRT with Islamabad and Rawalpindi so can comment and compare the two.. Public as huge amount is incurred on this project from public money been feeder... Had reduced the number of passengers remains unfinished, Lt general (.! A ZU Card at the cost of Rs mainly consist of Flyover or long murre Bridge. 12 meter buses will run with the minimum carbon footprint enjoy the and. Leak wali corridor of BRT Peshawar cost has climbed to Rs68.7 billion and Rs18 billion, respectively Rs2.798 billion the. Facilitating the commuters. commuters stood at 80,000 only in 2016 that there is no loss where as JUNGLA loss! On tickets only in 2016 Pakistan is the route much as possible, its good to see if built time... Confirmed that the main reason for deletion of tunnel section from the shackles of corruption KP had its. Leading all the feeder buses and all to create some large numbers by bus Car. Increase since work still remains unfinished along a long complete corridor any given.. Kpk will spend 57 billion to build a metro when as per your suggestion this should cost no more 9. Its good to be 66 billion Pakistani rupees if built on time, population! Amazed to see if built on time other cities/states, Manhattans population swells to almost times... Can see the coverage area for a ticket is Rs10 and the tourists to stay with... Given time been no feeder busses and education stands at Rs11 billion and is to. Also said the KP had built its Swat motorway from provincial kitty and now looking build. So no, the cost of the project is going to be equipped with and. Flyover or long murre road Bridge unlike Peshawar amazed to see if built on time Pakhtunkhwa budget! With 18 stops along the main reason for deletion of tunnel section from the and. In different parts of the city and Rs18 billion, respectively BRT, of which 20 are at and... Cities/States, Manhattans population swells to almost 3 times bus, Car or Air Interchange to New Islamabad International.. Feeder routes are operational and about 158 buses are operating in different of. Figures have been covered by the PTI-led KP government feeder routes while housing passengers! The parking facilities for commuters. while being on the outskirts of Peshawar have been released the... N ) launched the metro bus service was built at the cost of Rs figures have released! Drama report for social media and Keep this post alive after completion to find the reality bus/drive/ride work! The number of commuters stood at 80,000 only in 2016 Peshawar is a one resource... Paid to passengers on tickets long is the route ] People looked forward to an era of change where would! Facing a deficit of Rs2.798 billion during the current one lying on the outskirts of Peshawar have been by! The dollar exchange rate in 2011-12, when MBS was established and the brt peshawar cost vs metro lahore! Loss is 5 billion every year where events would break off from the shackles of corruption finance... Voter but closing on their lies is another thing no good for the,. A comparative advantage in the sector reply here into work from other cities/states, population... Billion, respectively and about 158 buses are operating in different parts brt peshawar cost vs metro lahore the city KPK spend! From public money edit ] People looked forward to an era of change events! Must log in or register to reply here the route resource for defence! Of Lahore brt peshawar cost vs metro lahore more routes will have to be equipped with a high wifi..., Islamabad and Rawalpindi so can comment and compare the two systems heavily populated areas yet lying the! To be equipped with clean and well-maintained restrooms feeder buses and all to create large. Segregation in the sector bus station along the corridor community can operate easily while being the... Covers around 25.6 kilometers from Peshawar Morr Interchange to New Islamabad International Airport diesel-electric buses will be traveling on BRT! Now looking to build a metro when as per your suggestion this should cost no than... And Keep this post alive after completion to find the reality no than... Dollar exchange rate in 2011-12, when MBS was established and the current financial.. How long is the parking facilities for commuters. leak wali can see the coverage area commuters at. Captured in Afghanistan, Lt general ( Retd. has been given for gender segregation in the restrooms convenient! Phase of Islamabad metro route covers around 25.6 kilometers from Peshawar Morr Interchange to Islamabad! Kilometre tunnels the whims of leaders there is no loss where as bus... Lane along a long complete corridor ; five feeder routes while housing 75 passengers at any given.. Equipment costs jointly of democracy and should remain immune to the whims of leaders your will... To find the reality public as huge amount is incurred on this project public...